Recently, people on youtube have asked me about my opinions on the Kingdom Hearts games by Square Enix. I was asked this when I was talking to a few friends about The World Ends With You; a game that was done by the same development team. They were shocked to hear that I don't really like the KH series, so I decided to lay out my reasons why.
The following as ALL opinion based and should not be taken to heart. I know many people, some of who are my best friends, who love these games, and theres nothing wrong with that. These are just my thoughts on the subject. ALSO: I'm only going to point out things from the first game, as its the only one Iv'e played/seen played all the way through.
1. The Concept: I think its cool when crossover events in gaming happen. Marvel vs Capcom, Street Fighter X Tekkon, these are great ideas, but RPG characters+Disney? They don't really belong in the same room, let alone the same game. Oh I can already hear you now, "YOU JUST HATE IT BECAUSE YOU HATE DISNEY!!." That's not true, most of my great early childhood memories come from Disney. Toy Story, Beauty and the Beast, and Mulan are some of the greatest examples of children's films, but did you ever want to play a video game about them? (Maybe Toy Story) Okay now lets reverse the argument. "OH YOU ONLY HATE IT BECAUSE YOU HATE RPGs!" As mentioned above, TWEWY is one of my all time favorite games, so I think I'm not going to be jumping on the RPG hate wagon anytime soon. Iv'e played games like, FF 1-7, Golden Sun, Chrono Trigger, Fire Emblem, Dragon Quest 9, Radiant Historia, and the Shin Megami Tensei games, I KNOW what a good RPG is, and the entirety of Kingdom Hearts is NOT a good example of this in my opinion. Simply put, KH has a lousy story, empty characters, and no clear footing for what it wants to be.
2. The Story: Okay lets be brief, what is the story of Kingdom Hearts? Lets look at the first game. Three kids, Sora (the bland main character), Riku (the emo loner best friend), and Kairi (blandy Mc bland heroine) live on an island (and apparently have no parents) and are setting out to go explore the world and sail out to new lands. A dark force comes and rains on their parade and takes away Kairi (Sora's childhood friend/jail bait) and Riku. Now Sora has to travel from Disney World to Disney World to find them. Meanwhile, King Mickey, (Yeah he's actually a king in this game. Its not too far from actually happening RL in my book) the guy who keeps the dark force at bay has gone missing, and now his best agents Donald and Goofy have to go looking for him. They meet up with Sora and team up to help him. And then their is literally no REAL plot events until the end of the game, which is just them finding the King and Riku and using the keyblade to seal away darkness.......only then to be released in the next game.
What the hell!!? How do you do that? How do you make a JRPG with a plot I can write out in literally 3 minutes! That kinda thing is INEXCUSABLE! A JRPG is a game that is primarily driven by its plot, and Kingdom Hearts has almost none of it beyond: Go to Disney World, Fight Heartless, Beat Boss, RIKU!!!! WHY!?!? Rinse and repeat. If you told me to write out the plot of Golden Sun, a GOOD JRPG, it would take me hours and pages of description. Bottom Line, the story is WEAK. Its the second worst thing about these games besides the characters. Speaking of which.....
3. The Characters: When most people claim that all RPGs involve dumb looking pre-teens with obnoxious catch phrases trying to save the world, this is one of the game series they draw ammo from. I'm going to be brutally honest here, the original Kingdom Hearts characters (besides the trademarked Disney/Square Enix ones) are all HORRIBLE! Every single one of then.
 |
Sora, a character
without character |
First lets talk about our lead, Sora. He's a spunky pre teen who wants to rescue his friends. And thats all their is to him. We get no clue about his past, his dreams, his motivations, and his views of the world. He's BLAND. He has no outstanding talents or traits, other than spouting out one-liners and being preachy, and has almost NO development by the end of the main story. Really Square? This is the character I'm supposed to relate to? An anime version of Justin Bieber with Ronald Mc Donald shoes? No thanks.
 |
Has all the personality
of a wet dish rag.
A beige dish rag |
Now lets talk about Sora's foil character Riku. Did you ever watch Naruto? You remember the character Sasuke? Thats Riku in a nut shell, A whiny emo piss tard who is never satisfied with anything he has, and always wants more power. He's the moody loner character that otaku fan girls fawn over because they think he's "Deep" or "Misunderstood." He's neither, he's just a git who needs to get over himself. Moving on!
 |
Useless.
This girl makes Princess Peach
look dependable by comparison |
Now we come to the worst offender of all. The weakest of the weak characters of this game, Kairi. We've all heard the expression damsel in distress, a woman who needs a man to rescue her and then be the reward to him, and Kairi is LOWER than that. She contributes nothing, 0%, zilch to the overall plot and story, except for providing an underage character that hentai artists beat off to and not feel guilty about doing so. Kairi is a character that doesn't need to be in this game. You could take her out and nothing would change. She's more useless than Sakura from Naruto. Thats right I just said that! MORE USELESS THAN SAKURA! Thats an all time low if I ever heard it.
4. The Combat: This is perhaps the only aspect of the Kingdom Hearts games that I like. Combat is fast paced and exciting, and you have a wide variety of spells and attacks to use. You can even set your spells and abilities to the four available direction buttons like hot keys, which comes in handy when fighting bosses. When your controlling your single character (Sora), everything is fine, but the game has a system where you have two computer player allies running around flinging spells and attacking enemies, and this is where things can get problematic. The AI on your allies never does what you want them to do. For example, if you want Donald your mage to heal you with a spell, he will only do so when he feels like it, and just stands by while you get mauled by a dark monstrosity. That, or they run head first into enemy attackers and suicide themselves like Kamikazes and die. This means you constantly have to be healing them with potions/cure spells of your own, and have less time to get an attack in on the opposition.
CONCLUSION: Kingdom Hearts is a game with a cool concept poorly executed with a bad plot and worse characters thrown together with an alright gameplay system. So the final score is 1/4 for me. It has potential to be great, but is so up its own ass with spin off game after spin off game, that I don't ever see it happening.